Quantcast
 

Polyurethane Condoms and STIs

Wed, 06/27/2007 - 10:00am by DearSugar
6,722 Views - 10 comments

Being that today, June 27, is National HIV Testing Day, I thought it'd be a great time to chat about protecting yourself from the emotional and physical damage of HIV and other STIs (sexually transmitted diseases).

Latex condoms protect you 100% from STIs, but what about polyurethane condoms like Avanti and Trojan Supra? Are they just as effective?

Source and Source


10 Comments Add a Comment

  • laurasugar's picture
    laurasugar
    1

    I'm not sure where you heard that latex condoms are 100% effective against sexually transmitted diseases (although they are the best option if you are sexually active) and its irresponsible to disseminate this misinformation.

    Latex condoms, with perfect use, protect very well against diseases that involve an exchange of bodily fluids (ex: HIV) but don't have quite as great a track record with diseases that can be passed by any genital contact with sores (ex: herpes).

    Polyurethane condoms do offer protection but should only be used if you are allergic to latex as they are not as reliable as latex (more slipping and breaking).

    Here is an excellent medical website that goes into all of this in greater detail.

    http://www.youngwomenshealth.org/malecontraceptives1.html

    1 year 23 weeks ago Report Comment
  • laurasugar's picture
    laurasugar
    2

    Wow. I just looked at the quiz results. How unfortunate that you are giving young, potentially sexually active women this misinformation.

    1 year 23 weeks ago Report Comment
  • t0xxic's picture
    t0xxic
    3

    Least shes trying damn she shouldnt even have to. its parents that need to be doing this.

    1 year 23 weeks ago Report Comment
  • tyffi's picture
    tyffi
    5

    Actually, there's no 100% safety by using condoms. They are safe - like in 98%, but there's still a risk left. False handling, old condom, incidents while opening, and so on.

    And as far as I know there aren't enough tests yet to say whether Polyurethane condoms are as safe as the latex ones, or not. They are an alternative for those who are allergic against latex, though, and it's assumed they'll be as effective as the 'normal' ones.

    1 year 22 weeks ago Report Comment
  • ash_marisa's picture
    ash_marisa
    6

    Dear, I think the concern referred to the statement
    "Latex condoms protect you 100% from STIs", which is of course not true.

    1 year 22 weeks ago Report Comment
  • laurasugar's picture
    laurasugar
    7

    Here is a quote from the Go Ask Alice website you provided that you purport claims that polyurethane is as good as latex...

    "Studies have shown that with typical use (used inconsistently or incorrectly some of the time and consistently and correctly other times), latex condoms are more likely to do the job better than polyurethane condoms."

    and another...

    "Compared to latex condoms, polyurethane condoms are less elastic and looser-fitting, making them slightly more likely to break or slip off."

    I also wonder at why you would cite so many sources targeted toward a male, homosexual audience for your clearly female audience.

    The website I provided above is published by a hospital and targeted to a female audience.

    1 year 22 weeks ago Report Comment
  • FitSugar's picture
    FitSugar
    8

    I would have to agree with my friend DearSugar on this one. When either latex or polyurethane condoms are used correctly (meaning they don't tear, break, or slip off) they will protect you from STI's when you have vaginal intercourse.

    Of course if either condom is old, slips off, or breaks while you're having sex, than you won't be protected.

    Avanti polyurethane condoms fit more like latex condoms. If the man has a slightly larger penis size - go for the Trojan Supras.

    1 year 22 weeks ago Report Comment
  • DearSugar's picture
    DearSugar
    9

    Hello again laurasugar -

    I just checked out the "Go Ask Alice"" website and the sentence right after the one you cited says "But, this isn't to say that polyurethane condoms are ineffective — they are, certainly, quite effective. In fact, they've passed the U.S. Food and Drug Administration's (FDA) rigorous tests and have gained the FDA's stamp of approval for sale in the United States as an effective method of contraception and HIV prevention."

    Also, the websites I mentioned in my above comment are about safe sex and facts concerning condoms - they aren't geared toward a male homosexual audience. They offer factual info about sex and male condom use. Could you clarify why you thought that?

    The point I'm making is that both latex and polyurethane condoms (when used CORRECTLY) during vaginal or anal sex are effective at protecting you against STIs. Of course if you want to be completely protected - have you and your partner get tested BEFORE getting intimate.

    1 year 22 weeks ago Report Comment
  • laurasugar's picture
    laurasugar
    10

    The following sentence does not, by any means, say that the polyurethane condoms are AS effective as latex, I assume to ease the minds of those people with latex sensitivity. Everything else aside, you have failed to address the misinformation regarding condoms being 100% effective against STI's. They simply are not. They CAN protect against STI's but do not in every case.

    1 year 18 weeks ago Report Comment

Leave a Comment

To post comments, please sign in or register.



Morsels of goodness, delivered daily.

Enter your email below:
 
 
 
 
 
 

Three Ways To Get Answers:

  1. Group Therapy: Submit your question anonymously to our great community.
  2. Dear Sugar: Send your questions directly to me.
  3. Sunday Confessionals: Write in asking for forgiveness and have others vote for your redemption.
 
 
 
 
 
 
Astrology.com
Enter your birth date:













©1976-2008 Sugar Inc. | Privacy (updated July-4-2008) | Terms of Use | Copyright Policy | Advertise | Contact Us