Quantcast
 

Ask E. Jean for DearSugar: I Found My Boyfriend's X-Rated Videos

Wed, 05/09/2007 - 10:38pm by E Jean Carroll
19,753 Views - 34 comments

Dear E. Jean,
I’ve been with my boyfriend for a little over a year-and-a-half. I’d seen some video tapes in the top drawer of his dresser, while helping him put away laundry. Of course my curiosity got the best of me and I finally watched two of three tapes this last weekend when he was playing golf. I know I shouldn’t have viewed them; and now I deeply regret doing so.

One of the tapes was of my boyfriend and an old ‘friend’ in a hotel having sex. The second tape was my boyfriend having sex with the same girl while someone else video taped it. At some points, it looked to be a fourth person in the room. The video was very graphic. I’ll spare you the details. The videos are dated from a couple years ago.

I realize this girl is from his past; but what bothers me is he still has the tapes! I can't get the images of him and her out of my head. And it disgusts me to know he allowed someone to shoot the two of them having sex.

How can I tell him how I feel without admitting I violated his privacy and watched the tapes? Should I secretly throw them away? I love him very much and I want to move on but I don't know how I can while keeping my anger bottled up like this. Help!

To see E. Jean's answer, read more

MY DEAR KUMQUAT: Ugh! How horrendous! Give me your halfwit boyfriend’s address. I want to take a running kick at his XXX. Not because he enjoyed a couple of diverting romps, (after all humans lead deep, frenzied, poetic, dangerous, tender, erotic lives); and not because he had himself video’d by a dumb cluck (you must keep an open mind about this), but because he ignored the Rules of Sex Tapes: Shoot it. Savor it. Bury it.

Note: Putting the videos in the top drawer⎯⎯ Traditional in all cultures as belonging to the girl friend⎯⎯ Is not burying them. It’s advertising them.

The wisest course is to forget it. You’ve annihilated the old girlfriend from your mind, do the same with the tapes. However, if you absolutely can’t let the matter rest (and apparently you were nearly flayed alive when you viewed the images), speak to him. Confess you broke his trust and watched the tapes. Then calmly and intelligently ask him to get rid of them. Don’t bully. Don’t judge. Don’t uncork your “bottled up” anger like a jealous dingbat.

Or, you can do what I did when I found my boyfriend’s cache of photos in which he was seen in several surprising positions with a lithe young lady with a vivid shade of red hair. (And they weren’t yogi positions either.) When he walked in the front door after work, I admitted nothing. I simply met him with a smile and two glasses of Veuve Clicquot.

The fact that I was standing in front of a glittering shrine in which hung the sacred Speedo's belonging to two old boyfriends, both Olympic butterfliers, plus every photo I owned of me smooching other guys, said everything I needed to say. I handed him the glass. I also slipped him a particularly heinous shot of the redhead. As he leaned nearer the flickering candlelight of the shrine to examine the photo, I whispered: “I’ll put mine in storage, Mr. Moose Balls, if you put yours.”

To see more advice from E. Jean visit Elle Magazine and AskEJean.com

Source


34 Comments Add a Comment

  • t0xxic's picture
    t0xxic
    2

    OMG I effin love your advice and scenario on what you did!!! LOVE IT! TOTALLY agree, I would have just said get rid of em and play dumb. But wonderful

    1 year 29 weeks ago Report Comment
  • a gentle rain's picture
    a gentle rain
    3

    E. Jean that sounds like it's from a movie, it's so good! I absolutely love how you handled it.

    1 year 29 weeks ago Report Comment
  • woodycakes's picture
    woodycakes
    4

    that was fabulous. I hope never to have the need to apply this, but in that odd event, Thanks E. Jean! Laughing out loud

    1 year 29 weeks ago Report Comment
  • Marci's picture
    Marci
    5

    I know what's in the past before a relationship is off limits and doesn't count in the scheme of things, but am I the only one bothered by the fact that this guy had someone else in the room to tape him having sex with that other girl? The sex tapes are one thing; the exhibitionism is another. Apparently he hasn't asked this girl to do the same. Yet. That may be why the tapes are in such an obvious spot? To introduce the topic? Just wondering.

    Anyway, I agree that he should put the tapes away somewhere. The top drawer is an invitation to you, and you accepted it on some level so now it's time for it to go.

    1 year 29 weeks ago Report Comment
  • almost famous's picture
    almost famous
    6

    well, i would be angry that he did in fact keep the tapes. However, the question is do you think he still has unfinished buisness with this girl? If someone is holding on to old gifts or personal items from a past lover, than they have something on the inside they are not willing to throw away! Maybe it was good sex with her or maybe she was just a wild chick he met at a club. however you want to put it it's still bad news!

    1 year 29 weeks ago Report Comment
  • jennifer76's picture
    jennifer76
    8

    I agree with Marci. This would be less of a jealousy thing for me and more of a whoa what kind of freaky deaky guy am I dating kind of thing. Shocked

    I don't think you should throw the tapes away. They're not yours. But, I do think you should talk to him about them. Seems like it's really bothering you. But, especially since he hasn't done anything *wrong*, don't attack him. Just try to talk to him about how you feel.

    1 year 29 weeks ago Report Comment
  • popgoestheworld's picture
    popgoestheworld
    9

    The thing I had the biggest problem with was.... who throws the thumbs up signal to a camera while having sex? Honestly, do people _really_ do that? Yuck.

    1 year 29 weeks ago Report Comment
  • brazilnut's picture
    brazilnut
    10

    I agree with E. Jean, if you can't put it out of your mind (who could!?) talk to him about it. I would make sure that you are good and relaxed and have a pretty good idea of what you want to say first, that's the only way that you are really going to be taken seriously.

    1 year 29 weeks ago Report Comment
  • popgoestheworld's picture
    popgoestheworld
    11

    BTW everyone, this is an old post, and the poster included a followup post already, in which she recounts how she did confront him and ask him to throw the tapes away. The outcome was that he kind of lied about what was on the tapes (admitted some raunchy activity, but claimed there were some party scenes he wanted to "save") and refused to toss them. No news as to what happened next but I sure am curious!!

    1 year 29 weeks ago Report Comment
  • FabSugar's picture
    FabSugar
    14

    Wow that is scandelicous! Between Dear & Pop we're going to have everyone's dirty little secrets exposed now! xo

    1 year 29 weeks ago Report Comment
  • DearSugar's picture
    DearSugar
    18

    GREAT advice E. Jean!
    Welcome, we are thrilled to have you!!

    -DearSugar

    1 year 29 weeks ago Report Comment
  • Tnkrbelli's picture
    Tnkrbelli
    19

    I actually would have to disagree! haha, I know I'm going to be the only one. I would just come out with the truth and I don't think I'd involve any "getting back at him" gestures. I'd tell him everything that I was thinking about because I find when you play games it can really complicate things more and you tend to compromise how you really feel. Unless you like to jab him back by showing him your old photos, I'd just be totally honest. Tapes in the top drawer??? Come on...he totally did not mind that you found them. Maybe he was feeling the need to spark some jealousy in you to spice things up! I'd probably just tell him to keep his baggage elsewhere and then I'd say "can we try that one position I saw on there..." , that would lighten the mood a bit! Eye-wink

    1 year 29 weeks ago Report Comment
  • GiggleSugar's picture
    GiggleSugar
    20

    What a juicy question, and great answer! I think it's true that you need to talk it out, and I agree with the basic idea that E. Jean has that it's important to somehow let him know that YOU have a past, too...you just don't keep it in a top drawer where he can find it!

    1 year 29 weeks ago Report Comment
  • popgoestheworld's picture
    popgoestheworld
    21

    Tnkrbelli - I'm with you too. No need to try to get back at someone like that - seems petty to me.

    1 year 29 weeks ago Report Comment
  • EJean's picture
    EJean
    22

    Thanks, darlings!

    I think PopSugar and DearSugar
    are the most delicious spots
    on earth!

    And the comments! Lord!
    Wittier than 99% of the
    websites out there.

    1 year 29 weeks ago Report Comment
  • lickety split's picture
    lickety split
    23

    i personally think that the fact that you are discusted by what you found is what is important here. this isn't something that can be "fixed" because it is what it is; those tapes are a part of his past.

    i was innterested by the suggestion that the tapes were left where you would find them. but still we don't know why he would want you to find them.l is it because he wants the same from you, because he feels guilty, because he likes the thrill of exposure?

    personally, i couldn't make a joke of this. it would be too weird to me (jmho). i would probably remove the tapes and wait for him to ask about them. then i would say "what tapes? what were they???" but honestly, it would just be an exercise of anger for me, because i would never get past the fact that he treated sex like a team sport and that is just not my style.

    1 year 29 weeks ago Report Comment
  • xoxoVSxoxo's picture
    xoxoVSxoxo
    24

    whatever his reason is, one's you have someone new in your life, who you've been with a while, all that ex stuff has got to go no matter what it.. specially that, "After all she is in his past right???"

    1 year 29 weeks ago Report Comment
  • asco00's picture
    asco00
    25

    Great advice, just priceless. I'm going to enjoy reading these!

    1 year 29 weeks ago Report Comment
  • gossipqueen's picture
    gossipqueen
    26

    I don't think i could ever get over the fact the he had SOMEONE ELSE film them while doing it...

    I'm not close minded...if a guy likes that that's fine as long as is not MY GUY! lol Eye-wink

    1 year 29 weeks ago Report Comment
  • FB1977's picture
    FB1977
    28

    Popgoestheworld, where's the follow-up she posted? I'd like to read...

    1 year 29 weeks ago Report Comment
  • imahoopie's picture
    imahoopie
    30

    I would wait til the next time we were putting away laundry, then pretend I just "discovered" the tapes and ask what they are. If he lies, like "oh, me with some friends" I would ask to watch the tapes as I grabbed them and headed for the VCR. Then I would bust him for lying and tell him to pitch them. If he was honest, I'd ask him why he keeps them. But really, the fact that he keeps them is saying something, no?

    Alternatively, she could always take the non-confrontational route: Buy him a DVD player and toss the VHS player while he's out, "as a surprise" and then he wouldn't be able to watch the tapes anymore!

    1 year 29 weeks ago Report Comment
  • kayden's picture
    kayden
    31

    E.Jean gave you some good advice..
    Start today off fresh and new..

    1 year 23 weeks ago Report Comment
  • NdHebert's picture
    NdHebert
    32

    I would be all sexy and drink some wine and say "hey, wouldnt it be fun to pop in a video while we yada yada yada?" and when you go to get his, if he freaks out thats when you can ask why.

    And then you 'find out', talk, and destroy.

    Maybe this is why my boyfriends never last long. Laughing out loud

    1 year 18 weeks ago Report Comment
  • ethiopian_princess's picture
    ethiopian_princess
    33

    ugh. don't TALK EVERYTHING TO DEATH.

    Really, as far as the images you now have burned into your corneas, you've only got yourself to blame. If you wanted to know what they were, you should have asked him. Too late now. Here are your options:
    *address it and have him lose trust in you
    *don't address it and have it eat away at you while picturing the other woman every time he touches you.

    there's nothing wrong with what he did. there's nothing necessarily wrong with the fact that he kept it or that he kept it in the top drawer. it's stupid, yes, but if emily post wrote on the topic, i must have missed that chapter. what you did was wrong.

    1 year 18 weeks ago Report Comment
  • Gizselle's picture
    Gizselle
    34

    this happened to me before but instead of just one girl there were like 8 of them. All shapes and sizes!! and none of them were with protection.
    I couldn't continue the relationship. EEW!

    1 year 18 weeks ago Report Comment

Leave a Comment

To post comments, please sign in or register.



Morsels of goodness, delivered daily.

Enter your email below:
 
 
 
 
 
 

Three Ways To Get Answers:

  1. Group Therapy: Submit your question anonymously to our great community.
  2. Dear Sugar: Send your questions directly to me.
  3. Sunday Confessionals: Write in asking for forgiveness and have others vote for your redemption.
 
 
 
 
 
 
Astrology.com
Enter your birth date: