Quantcast
 

You Asked: She Invited Her Family to My Wedding!

Tue, 04/22/2008 - 5:00am by DearSugar
1,070 Views - 37 comments

Dear Sugar,

My fiancé and I are pulling together our wedding on our own with no help from a wedding planner and minimal financial help from our families. We are trying to keep our guest list reasonable so that we can stick to our budget. This has proven to be difficult since we both have large extended families, so we've had to pick and choose who we're inviting. So imagine my surprise when my fiancé's brother's wife called me to insist that her parents (who I've never met) be invited to the wedding to care for her 2-year-old child. It would be one thing if she was a direct family member, but they are a few degrees removed. To add insult to injury, my fiancé's brother's wife is already bringing a nanny, which makes her request even more outlandish.

When she first asked me about this, she did ask, however as I told her about our budgeting concerns, she became increasingly adamant, and ending up basically instructing me to invite them. Since we are paying for 90 percent of this wedding, I feel like I should be able to just say no, but I don't want to start off my marriage on the wrong foot, this is part of his family after all. I'm really told but most of all astounded by her query. Do you have any advice?
— Broke Bride Brooke

To see DearSugar's answer read more.

Dear Broke Bride Brooke,

First and foremost, I must commend you and your fiancé for planning and hosting your wedding alone, I know that's not an easy task. Since you're sticking to a pretty tight budget here, I completely understand how you'd feel taken aback by this woman's request. Like you, I'd think having a nanny there to help care for her child would be more than enough, so something tells me there's more to her wanting her parents there. The etiquette for inviting quests is all very circumstantial, but at the end of the day, it's your wedding, not hers, so the choice is ultimately up to you and your fiancé.

Of course, starting off your marriage on the right foot is important, as is not burning any bridges, but it's even more important to not go into debt all because of one night — remember, it's about the marriage, not the wedding. So with that said, I'd talk it over with your fiancé, tell him how you feel and if you both see eye to eye, I advise you to say no to her. Now if your fiancé feels that it's important to have them there, unfortunately you're going to have to extend the invite — while this is your special day, it's his, too. I think we can agree that this was a pretty presumptuous request, but you should not, by any means, feel badly for saying no if that's the decision you make. I hope I was of some help, and good luck.

To see all of our wedding coverage, check out IDoSugar.com.

Source

on Yahoo!

37 Comments Add a Comment

  • missbanana's picture
    missbanana
    1

    wow. that lady has got some balls to "instruct" you to invite them. shes got issues
    you seem too nice to stand your ground. but you should. =) goodluck

    30 weeks 2 days ago Report Comment
  • carak's picture
    carak
    2

    one of my cousins got married 2 or 3 years ago. he had his brother's daughter as one of the flower girls. his brother's wife wanted her parents to come to the wedding since their granddaughter was going to be a flower girl. the cousin who was getting married & his fiance didn't really know the sister-in-laws parents & were trying to keep costs down on their wedding. eventually they ended up inviting the sister-in-law's parents, but they didn't come because they said they felt unwelcome or something. needless to say since then the sister-in-law has been pretty cold (and sometimes rude) towards my cousin's wife.

    i understand it's your wedding, but you're also marrying into a family. a wedding is one day and family is forever.

    30 weeks 2 days ago Report Comment
  • jennifer76's picture
    jennifer76
    4

    All these wedding drama questions lately have made me veery happy that we had an awesomely fun, stress free party/wedding at our house instead of a giant dramarama money pit.

    30 weeks 2 days ago Report Comment
  • skigurl's picture
    skigurl
    5

    first of all, it's 100% in your hands: just don't send an invitation to her parents. if they show up anyway, then that is absolutely rude, and will be noted as such.

    in order to explain to her, have your brother do it. it's his crazy family.

    30 weeks 2 days ago Report Comment
  • fleurfairy's picture
    fleurfairy
    6

    If you back down now, imagine how much else you'll have to do for her in the future. Don't be a pushover, this is YOUR day and your money. I would politely, but very firmly tell her that you do not have the money to invite superfluous people and if the child needs to be watched, maybe you should tell her to leave the kid at home with a sitter. Children at a wedding is always more of a hassle anyway.

    30 weeks 2 days ago Report Comment
  • Trixie6's picture
    Trixie6
    7

    You need to talk it over with your fiancee. If he agrees with you that her demands are outlandish, which they are, HE should be the one to call his brother and explain the situation.

    30 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • Kristinh1012's picture
    Kristinh1012
    8

    I wouldn't invite her ass either if she's going to act like a spoiled b*tch. Sounds like a control freak. She needs to leave her daughter at her parents house or have her parents come to her house and baby-sit.

    30 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • Kristinh1012's picture
    Kristinh1012
    9

    Oh I got caught up, sorry, I meant to also say, you should have a talk with your fiance. He should be the one to go to his brother and explain things. It's his brothers wife, I'm sure he's got lots of experience in how to handle her insane demands.

    30 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • vanprooyen's picture
    vanprooyen
    10

    The fiance's brother's wife is way out of line. If she has a nanny then she doesn't need her parents there, too. It's too much to ask.

    30 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • mn48225's picture
    mn48225
    11

    I think you should talk to your fiance' about it. I think this is a sticky situation because it's your in-law's in-laws; it might be awkward for them to deal with it, too. I hope that this situation gets resolved but if it doesn't, just breathe and try not to let this spoil your moment.

    30 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • lickety split's picture
    lickety split
    12

    if someone is going to be unhappy on your wedding day do you want it to me you or her? if you pik you then get ready for more of the same from her during your marriage. if you pick her, you'll have 4 more seats available for your wedding.

    30 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • Berlin's picture
    Berlin
    13

    speak with her one-on-one, face-to-face...she'll be a lot less likely to be so pushy when she has to look at you, and stress that it is impossible to do because of budget restraints. Remember...you may be marrying into the family, but it is your and your new husband that must deal with the debt afterwards, and you don't want to be starting off with THAT either! If you need to, express the concerns to your new mother in law for help. More than likely her parent's don't know that you are paying for it yourself and are having to stretch the list out, so it's probably just her being selfish. Does she know that you're having to cut people? You can't just assume that she does, a lot of people don't take budget constraints seriously until you let them know (like a child) that you are having to cut those that are close to you, so those that aren't certainly aren't going to be able to come.

    She'll tough it up, and if not, hell, it's YOUR day! She'll have hers. But again, I'd talk to her face-to-face, just you 2, and see if that helps any.

    30 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • linb's picture
    linb
    14

    Uninvite the brother's wife. Problem solved. No babysitters needed - she can stay home and watch them herself.

    30 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • cubadog's picture
    cubadog
    15

    This is why I am going to have a destination wedding or elope. I do not want the drama. While family is forever that is no reason to invite people you do not know. I also agree with the kids free concept, I have never really understood why people insist that children need to be a part of it anyway.

    30 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • 7kimba7's picture
    7kimba7
    16

    The nanny is already coming? I would tell her to choose one- her parents or the nanny. And if she is bringing people to take care of the child, why are they attending the reception? usually when people bring "extras" to take care of kids, they watch them at the hotel while the parents party or something.
    I would probably tell her I would love to meet her parents and have them over for dinner or something, but unfortunately, you don't have it in your budget to invite additional people. If they would like to spend time with their grandchild and see the ceremony, they are welcome to attend the ceremony but not the reception.

    30 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • Liss's picture
    Liss
    17

    I would tell her to leave the kid at home. But you should talk to your fiance about it and see how he feels.

    30 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • MarinerMandy's picture
    MarinerMandy
    18

    I am so flabergasted by the demands that people put on guest lists for weddings. It is your wedding and you have the right to celebrate the beginning of a huge change in your life with the people you choose. My fiance and I are doing a quicky, backyard barbeque style wedding. Because of the short notice, many of my family members can't make it, yet my future mother in law is insisting that we invite her neighbors and my futer father in law's friends from work...all people neither me nor my fiance know all the while not contributing a dime to the cost. I think weddings bring out some of the worst sides of people and it's important to compromise but to also stand your ground. You are allowing her to bring her child and a nanny, I think that is compromise enough.

    30 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • Lele777's picture
    Lele777
    19

    I too paid for 80% of my own wedding and invited who I could afford. THat was our day!!! Nobody esles day to tell us how to do it!! We had a modest reception and all children left after they ate and saw the presents opened and sharing of cake including my six year old son!!! Then we had our friends spin records and danced the night away. there was no open bar. Our friends and family bought their own drinks throughout the night because they knew we were pressed for funds!!!!! family and friends should be understanding that you are doing the best you can with what you have. Thank God I have great people in my life.

    30 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • vmruby's picture
    vmruby
    20

    Wow she has big ones......and the nanny is already invited!Sounds like she been overly indulged by someone and needs to be told that the universe doesn't revolve around her or her demands.Yeah, i agree with the others who said to tell her to leave the child at home with her parents.Talk to your fiance. It's his brother he should have stepped in already and put a stop to this ridiculous BS.You both need to stand your ground because there's a budget you have to stick to and she needs to understand that regardless.What part of she doesn't get to tell you who to invite to your wedding doesn't she get. If she refuses to accept it, then put her in her place and promptly uninvite her spoiled arse.

    I feel sorry for your future brother in law.If she carries on like this normally then his life must be a living hell....

    30 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • lizzylu49's picture
    lizzylu49
    21

    Some people get so worked up about what to do with their kids when attending a wedding.

    Hire a sitter. It's one night. If you can't do that, then stay at home with them.

    If you're feeling generous, you could also offer to hire a sitter for people bringing their kids, but this is by no means required.

    30 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • ninjastarlett's picture
    ninjastarlett
    22

    I've seen listings on craigslist and such looking for a sitter or two to watch several kids during the wedding. Maybe that's something you could consider?

    30 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • stayplus's picture
    stayplus
    23

    Look, you already have enough on your plate without this clown causing you unnecessary trouble.

    Who cares if you burn your bridges. You said that both of you have big extended families so you might not even see her at future family gatherings.

    Plus, this woman sounds like the type who thinks they have a god-given right to demand favours from anyone. So it's better to not be friends with her anyway.

    30 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • JaimeLeah526's picture
    JaimeLeah526
    24

    It's your wedding. If you don't want her parents there and can't afford for them to be there than you have to say no. She's already got a nanny. If that isn't enough maybe she shouldn't come either.

    30 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • avettafawna's picture
    avettafawna
    26

    Why is it always the women who have to deal with these problems? Talk about it with your fiance, and if he also doesn't want them there then confront his sister-in-law and/or brother together. I know that you don't want to cause family trouble before you even get married, but the reality is that you're not the one causing trouble, she is, and if she is so bossy as to invite other people to YOUR wedding, then she is probably a troublemaker that will continue to cause trouble even after she gets her way. It is not your responsibility to accomidate such a vile breach of etiquette on her part.

    For the record, I really feel for you. She sounds like a horrid nightmare and I would hate to have to spend the rest of my life dealing with her.

    30 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • Bearwoman's picture
    Bearwoman
    27

    Listen to Flowerelf person here. If you back down now, you might be opening a door for this woman to walk all over you in the future. Best of luck and congratulations, I hope your wedding goes well.

    30 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • PJ PJ PJ's picture
    PJ PJ PJ
    28

    Wow, she sounds like she lives in her own little world & has no idea of what budget constraints are.

    It's your day. Stand your ground. Better yet, have your husband deal with it, since it's his family.

    30 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • 0danielle0's picture
    0danielle0
    29

    Wow, she has a lot of nerve! Who brings a nanny to a wedding?! Tell her no.

    30 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • graylen's picture
    graylen
    30

    Umm, if she HAS A NANNY, why is she bringing the kid to the wedding in the first place????

    30 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • Hannah426's picture
    Hannah426
    32

    I would absolutely say no. Like the letter said, it's not just about that one night, it's about the marriage as a whole. I know that inviting two more people isnt gonna cost that much more but still. You have to think about your future financial situation. Do you want to jump off your marriage being in some awful debt?

    30 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • girlfriday's picture
    girlfriday
    33

    Damn that girl is BALLSY! Why can't the nanny stay with the kid AT HOME?

    Firstly, this is totally not your battle. Your fiance needs to talk to HIS brother.

    I hate how you already read in Dear Abby or whatever, how women have these problems with their mothers-in-law and I'm thinking "where is their husband in this?!?"

    Seriously. This is between him and his brother. And if your fiance's brother isn't man enough then your brother can address his sister in law. My belief that that we have to fight our own battles where our family is concerned. I would NEVER allow my (future) fiance to have to stand up to my b*tchy sister in law. She's my problem.

    30 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • jillerin457's picture
    jillerin457
    35

    I'm so relieved to see everyone in agreement on this one! If you're paying for YOUR wedding, some random kid and her random grandparents shouldn't have a say. And like the others said, why does a kid need to be at a wedding in the first place?

    30 weeks 1 day ago Report Comment
  • vanprooyen's picture
    vanprooyen
    36

    We're having a "children's table" at our wedding in July that will be supervised by hired childcare professionals, who are only $75 an hour. I don't want kids running around the dining area like screaming during the toasts. Maybe that's something you could consider? $75 an hour might be cheaper than inviting the grandparents. It would be at my wedding anyways, where each additional guests costs mucho dinero!!!

    30 weeks 21 hours ago Report Comment
  • lizadilly's picture
    lizadilly
    37

    Yech. I'm a single girl, and the more I read about weddings the more I think "NO THANK YOU!"

    With two parents and a nanny, I think there are enough adults there that one of them can stay sober and take care of a kid. If she can't take care of her own kid than she either shouldn't bring the kid or she shouldn't come.

    If she can't accept that, put it to her this way: "I simply do not have the money to pay for your childcare. If you would like to donate the $X per head cost for your parents, THEN they can come." When she sees how much money you're really talking about, she may back down and realize what a twat she's being.

    30 weeks 20 hours ago Report Comment

Leave a Comment

To post comments, please sign in or register.



Morsels of goodness, delivered daily.

Enter your email below:
 
 
 
 
 
 

Three Ways To Get Answers:

  1. Group Therapy: Submit your question anonymously to our great community.
  2. Dear Sugar: Send your questions directly to me.
  3. Sunday Confessionals: Write in asking for forgiveness and have others vote for your redemption.
 
 
 
 
 
 
Astrology.com
Enter your birth date: